disable Live Photo permanently

I think you may be doing this wrong.. if you turn OFF the switch in Settings > Camera > Preserve Settings, then you are turning off the preservation of your setting and it would therefore automatically turn Live back on (it says this in the description below the button). so that switch should be toggled to the right, with green showing, then you should go into the Camera app and tap the 'bullseye' looking icon with outer dashed line so that it has a slash thru it, which is turning off Live Photos.

this article discusses everything I've commented on and has pictures.. section at the bottom for turning it off

Take and edit Live Photos - Apple Support

Gigi6623 wrote:

1. Here are the steps to turn this feature off permanently

Navigate to the Settings app.

2. Tap Camera > Preserve Settings

3. Switch the toggle next to Live Photos off. (Green means on. Gray means off.)

Your instructions are incorrect.

Go to the place you are telling the OP to go to on your phone and read what it says by the switch.

Then if that doesn't convince you, read the last section of the link I posted... where #3 says to turn the switch ON, not off

Did you follow the 2nd thing I said to do? Your second screenshot shows Live Photo is still on. Did you turn it off once you toggled that switch in settings?

Flipping the switch in Settings doesn't actually turn Live Photo on or off. It preserves the last setting that you had in the camera app. Therefore you have to turn off Live Photo in the camera app in order for it to be preserved.

Here are the steps to turn this feature off permanently

1. Navigate to the Settings app.
2. Tap Camera > Preserve Settings
3. Switch the toggle next to Live Photos off. (Green means on. Gray means off.)