Game Center saved menu will not load up after signing into my main account. It does for other accounts.

I play a game and I have 3 accounts on on same phone. I signed out of my main account on Game Center signed into alternate account. But when I signed back to main Game Center account opened the game app it won’t pop up the Game Center saved menu which it should automatically and I don’t have a problem signing in to other accounts just this account in particular. Really hope someone has an idea what’s going on I’ve tried a soft reset, turned phone off and deleted the game app nothing has work. would like to get to the root of the problem.

[Re-Titled by Moderator]