You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Can I Use iMac As Monitor For Mac Mini ?

My imac 2017 has an issue.first of all Ventura is the last Os that will work on this hardware according to apple.

then there is a problem.when i mac is on sleep ,sometimes doesn't wake up.i disconnect a usb hub and the ethernet but still no reaction.

i force to end its operation by the energy button.and then i restart my imac and everything is fine.also in random timelines i hear a gling-metal noise like 2 coins are dropping into a slot which i read here that might be the hard disc going to failure.

so i was thinking of saving the screen of my imac and use it for a new mac mini .if its possible to connect the 2 devices together and work.

i found this article.its about a connection between an imac 's screen and a pc. and i thought that if it really works with a pc then it should work with a mac mini.


[Edited by Moderator]

iMac 21.5″, macOS 13.7

Posted on Jan 16, 2025 1:16 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 16, 2025 1:30 PM

I'm unfamiliar with that third-party app.


The traditional Target Display Mode won't work here: Use your iMac as a display with target display mode - Apple Support — your iMac is too new.


Your gear is also too old for AirPlay to Mac: Continuity features and requirements for Apple devices - Apple Support


If your iMac hardware is failing, whether the hard disk drive or something else, it's anybody's guess what happens.


Diagnostics won't find transient errors, but might find some errors: Use Apple Diagnostics to test your Mac - Apple Support


If the iMac hard disk is failing, a potential workaround: How to Setup and Use an External SSD as your startup disk… - Apple Community

33 replies

Jan 16, 2025 2:25 PM in response to macman1585

If that Mac was working, you could use it as a second screen using Luna Display (Astropad). That workaround is not as good as a hardware connection to a real display – and the Astropad site itself says that Luna Display is not suitable for high-motion content such as from gaming or video editing.


However, if the iMac is failing, there's no guarantee that it would even work with Luna Display. It has bo be able to run, to run the Luna Display software.


It sounds like you need to buy a real monitor for the new Mac mini.


I know of only three 27" 5120x2880 (5K) monitors on the market – the Apple Studio Display, one from LG, and one from Samsung. The LG and Samsung ones list for more than $1000, but often sell for a street price of about $800 to $950, making them less expensive than the $1600+ Studio Display.


If you're willing to compromise a bit on the resolution, there are plenty of 27" 3840x2160 (4K) monitors – and you can get some with IPS panels and near-100% coverage of sRGB for as little as $300 - $350.

Jan 16, 2025 3:46 PM in response to MrHoffman

MrHoffman wrote:

Servant of Cats wrote:

...I know of only three 27" 5120x2880 (5K) monitors on the market – the Apple Studio Display, one from LG, and one from Samsung...

ASUS ProArt PA27JCV, and the just-announced BenQ PD2730S, too.


It's good news that more are coming out.


I wonder how that Asus ProArt PA27JCV connects. The description mentions USB-C (DisplayPort) but doesn't say anything about Thunderbolt. The BenQ PD2730S connects via Thunderbolt 4.

Jan 17, 2025 3:31 AM in response to MrHoffman

Thanks for your help..

unfortunately ,near me i have access only to this ssd https://www.samsung.com/us/computing/memory-storage/portable-solid-state-drives/portable-ssd-t5-500gb-mu-pa500b-am/


so if hard disc fails then my imac can still work with an external ssd?


how about the OS..Ventura is the last one on it and from what i read it will be outdated from updates ,in about 2-3 years meaning my imac wont work properly after these 2-3 years ,meaning get a new one.so is it worthy to give an extension of life to my imac investing to an external ssd?

i think that with a new ssd i cant have the latest OS even if i wanted to bcs my hardware can't support it anymore.or am i wrong?



Jan 17, 2025 11:32 AM in response to Servant of Cats

Servant of Cats wrote:



I may try to resurrect that Mac at some point, to run old 32-bit applications, but after getting nearly 14 years of use out of it, it seemed like time to move on.

so i do have some time since its only 7 years old.



No, it doesn't mean that your Mac "won't work properly after 2–3 years." It does mean that after 2-3 years, you will find it harder to get new applications that are compatible with that Mac … and you won't be getting security updates.

yeah, thats what i meant, it happen once when i went from sierra to Ventura until last year. i hadnt run any of the previous mac os versions before.


thanks for your answers. i guess i have 2 choices...run the mac with external ssd and see what happens( gain 5 years would be great) or wait until hard discs fails completely and move on to a new mac.

Jan 18, 2025 6:09 AM in response to macman1585

macman1585 wrote:

just remembered , my nephew has a 2011 imac which failed from motherboard. is its hard disc alive? its been 4 years since it has been used.will it fit to my 2017 imac if i try? well not me ,but a tech guy.


If you are talking about pulling the hard drive from the 2011 iMac to try to recover data from it, you could use something like this:


Other World Computing – OWC Mercury Elite Pro


Specifically, the "DIY Enclosure (Add your own 3.5-inch drive)".

Jan 19, 2025 11:03 AM in response to Old Toad

ok,lets take things one by one.


no i dont have fusion drive,no ssd.


i have never installed any app such as cleaning e.t.c.


also i have never run any of these diagnostic programs not even have installed any of them.i wanted to but opinions vary especially about etrecheck. i never had any serious problem to try them.


now about the hub. i am not sure what you mean about a self powered hub. the hub is a NTC hub ,i have it for almost 20 years ,has 6 ports ,i usually use 3 of them.it is connected with a usb cable to the imac port and with a power cord to the ups plug .


about the sleep mode.oh man, this is a vary debatable subject on the Internet community.many are for it and many against it. some told me ,do you switch off your phone, then why do that to your pc? and such opinions.that metals are doing a hard job trying to turn on the mac and that causes problems to hardware.some others say that in sleep mode imac uses more power e.t.c.

i dont know which is good for my hardware, i decide it to split my decision to both opinions. so i turn on my imac early in the morning and then for the rest of the day to put it in sleep mode when i don't use it.first screen saver for 5 min and then set it to sleep mode automatically.and late at night, i turn it off again until next morning.

i dont really know what you mean ''to go blank'' .what is that?




Jan 20, 2025 5:52 AM in response to MrHoffman


The suggestion was to power down the display, which can be configured in System Settings.

i tried to find the power down the display setting but there isnt on written like that in my ventura system settings.

is it the:

system settings> energy (the yellow button with the bulb) > turn on(activate) power nap ?


do you know the exact path in ventura? i am still learning that OS.

Jan 20, 2025 7:46 AM in response to Servant of Cats

I’d try some variation of the following command-line command, given it seems macOS 15 removed some settings from the GUI here:

sudo pmset -a displaysleep 5 sleep 15


That should cause the display to sleep after five minutes, and the Mac to sleep after fifteen minutes, regardless (-a) of the current power source. I might add -u with different settings when running on UPS. If there’s a UPS.


I don’t have a macOS 15 system handy to test.

Jan 21, 2025 11:55 AM in response to Servant of Cats

i assumed from your writings,mr Hoffman's actually, that he mentioned not to sleep mode the imac ,bcs in sleep mode the computer spins the drives ,so its not good for them.bcs no sleep mode, less use of hard drive.


but now you are telling me that if its not in sleep mode ,then the computer is running normally meaning that the drives will still spin and with normal speed, not lower one like in sleep mode. ,so whats the profit of going blank screen? what the screen has to do with my possible problem with the hard drive? unless its just an addional advice and still i dont get the use of it , since with just the display off the only thing that you gain is less use of screen.so save the screen,but thats not the case here.


i thought from what mr Hoffman mentioned that the problem with the hard drive comes from the added time of the spinning, not the added time of the display.

Jan 22, 2025 1:24 PM in response to Servant of Cats

ok, here are the settings on my ventura concerning the sleep mode and display:


system settings:


energy (orange box with white bulb)> put hard disk in sleep mode whenever is possible, I DEACTIVATED THAT

> activate power nap , I DEACTIVATED THAT

> wake up from sleep mode for internet access, i left it ACTIVATED


displays> prevent automatic sleep mode when screen is deactivated, I DEACTIVATED THAT


lock screen > how minutes after the screen saver will begin when screen is inactive (this is set by me to 5')

> how many minutes after the screen will be deactivated when it is inactive (this is set by me to 10')


require password after screensaver or deactivated screen (this is set by me to 15')


after i did all these settings and had some time with my imac ,i left it alone to see what will happen.


well, i had a screensaver ,then screen went black according to my settings. i left it for hours .when came back and tried to wake up the screen by pressing a key as usually, no response.

so i pressed the power button and screen woke up.but i had set the password code in my personal settings when from screen wake up.but i couldn't write anything on the password area.so i thought to connect the usb cable charger and connected it to the keyboard.that was that!it worked!i typed my password and took me into my os.but then mouse didn't work.


i pressed the power button again for a while until the message pop up appears saying /giving me the choice to restart my mac.i did that and then the mouse came back alive.


conclusion.with the hub disconnected ,certainly that wasn't the cause. sleep mode no more, so that wasn't the cause either.


so the cause is the bluetooth ,thats my conlusion.when screen goes black, trying to wake it up then i loose the bluetooth .bluetooth is off. not all the times i wake up the screen,maybe 2/10 times.its happens more often sometimes.

so why am i loosing the bluetooth connection for mouse and keyboard when trying to wake up the screen from black? does this has to do with hard disc as i initially thought ot it has to do with something else?


Can I Use iMac As Monitor For Mac Mini ?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.