Can't hear my track anymore when I pre-roll for a recording

When I place my playhead on a track where I already recorded my guitar, I press 'R' to record, then there is a 1 bar pre-roll. Up until a couple of days ago, I could hear my track, and it stopped where I started recording.

Yesterday, I opened my project, and now when I try to record, I can't hear the track I'm trying to record on during the 1-bar pre-roll. I hear all the other tracks, but not the one I'm re-recording over.

I usually don't use the Autopunch function, but even when I use the Autopunch, I still can't hear the track.

Same issue applies to any Audio tracks, however it works fine on Midi tracks.

I tried all the trouble shootings solutions provided by Apple. I re-installed Logic few times, turned off and on my computer and Interface (Focusrite Scarlett 18i20). Nothing seems to be working... I tried all the combinations of Input monitoring, no luck.

I feel like the solution might be easy but I can't think of anything...