Music app in Mac OS Tahoe ignoring Stop and Start times for Tracks

Ever since upgrading to Mac OS Tahoe, the Music app on my Mac has been ignoring stop and start times that I have manually set for various tracks. It does not seem to matter if they are purchased, imported from CD, or streamed from Apple Music. This has proved very frustrating to solve. This only happens on Mac, both my iMac and MacBook Pro. My iOS, iPadOS, and tvOS devices all follow the correct stop/start times. There was another thread about this way back around the time Catalina came out with some solutions that seemed to solve the problem. I have tried all of the listed solutions, still with no results. That thread was closed so I am opening this one.

iMac 27″

Posted on Sep 25, 2025 5:29 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Nov 19, 2025 3:48 AM

I confirmed it is a bug in the Music App UI directly in Mac OS 26.1 by doing this: double click any song the custom start time it is 100% ignored. Custom start time in 'get info' window is valid and enabled. Use the media keys on the Function Row or Touch Bar of the keyboard to navigate instead of the trackpad or mouse and custom start and stop times work completely fine.


The problem can be directly isolated to using the pointer vs using the keyboard media keys. My assumption here is the introduction of 'song transitions' which I disabled has broken part of the UI in the music app.


Seems like a bug. I can't imagine Apple would intentionally have different playback functionality based on using a mouse vs using the media keys on purpose. I reported this in the feedback app but need others to validate and escalate.

4 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Nov 19, 2025 3:48 AM in response to unknownposter1

I confirmed it is a bug in the Music App UI directly in Mac OS 26.1 by doing this: double click any song the custom start time it is 100% ignored. Custom start time in 'get info' window is valid and enabled. Use the media keys on the Function Row or Touch Bar of the keyboard to navigate instead of the trackpad or mouse and custom start and stop times work completely fine.


The problem can be directly isolated to using the pointer vs using the keyboard media keys. My assumption here is the introduction of 'song transitions' which I disabled has broken part of the UI in the music app.


Seems like a bug. I can't imagine Apple would intentionally have different playback functionality based on using a mouse vs using the media keys on purpose. I reported this in the feedback app but need others to validate and escalate.

Sep 26, 2025 7:08 AM in response to unknownposter1

Hey,


I recognized a similar behavior in Tahoe (and downgraded to Sequoia because of that), but it also appears to be present in Sequoia. What I found out by now is that it just seems to appear with .aif or .aiff-files, converting anything to any other format inc. .wav solves the issue and it again works as it should.


It also happens with .aiff-files related to track-individual eq settings and volume presets, also autofader and automatic volume control do not work with .aiff-files., for whatever reason. Extremely frustrating and, for my taste, indiscussable.

Nov 19, 2025 4:34 AM in response to Canadian Chad

Trying to confirm this on Sequoia 15.7.1, this is what I found out: Using .aiff-tunes in a playlist, a modified start time is recognized and correctly set when I change/choose tracks with the keyboard media keys. Modified stop times are still ignored, although the timer line shows it corrctly: The setted end time is simply ignored by the app, the track plays until its native end.


Still not working are track-related eq presets and the auto fader function in playlists, also track-related volume settings are ignored.

Music app in Mac OS Tahoe ignoring Stop and Start times for Tracks

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.