You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iMovie doesn’t read avc high L5.2 movie

Hello, I have following issue

I wanted to edit movie recorded (mp4, avc, high profile level 5.2) 4k 60fps. After uploading it into iMovie, it is totally black and only sound works. The same problem I can see after normal opening in quicktime. I really wouldn’t like to do conversions to any other formats before editing. The problem really frustrates me because the video can be played at my much older device with windows and doesn’t work at my mb pro 2019.

Any ideas? If I buy FCP license for example, can I be sure that it will handle it?

MacBook Pro 13", macOS 10.15

Posted on Feb 21, 2020 12:46 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 21, 2020 7:42 AM

iMovie supports 4k 30fps, but not 4k 60fps. That could be the issue. Also, iMovie prefers H.264 Mp4/AAC format. I realize that you would prefer not to do any conversions, but you could make a duplicate of your video and try converting that to the above format. That way you would still preserve your original. If the format is HEVC you might try converting that to H.264.


Reducing the resolution to 1080p sometimes cures the black screen issue. iMovie supports 1080p 60fps.


The release notes on Catalina 10.15.3 indicate some improvement re 4k editing, at least with the 16in. MacBook Pro, so you might update to that if you haven't already.


I don't know whether FCP would handle the 4k any differently.


-- Rich

5 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Feb 21, 2020 7:42 AM in response to MACkoo92

iMovie supports 4k 30fps, but not 4k 60fps. That could be the issue. Also, iMovie prefers H.264 Mp4/AAC format. I realize that you would prefer not to do any conversions, but you could make a duplicate of your video and try converting that to the above format. That way you would still preserve your original. If the format is HEVC you might try converting that to H.264.


Reducing the resolution to 1080p sometimes cures the black screen issue. iMovie supports 1080p 60fps.


The release notes on Catalina 10.15.3 indicate some improvement re 4k editing, at least with the 16in. MacBook Pro, so you might update to that if you haven't already.


I don't know whether FCP would handle the 4k any differently.


-- Rich

Feb 21, 2020 9:25 PM in response to MACkoo92

According to Apple's bulletin of August 2019, iMovie will export 4k video at 30 fps, and 1080p video at 60 fps, but not 4k video at 60 fps. If you are aware of different and more current information from Apple to the contrary I would appreciate it if you would refer me to it. It might help others who want to know.


https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205345


Before you say that my previous post is "not helpful" you might try the suggestions that I made, to see if a converted video will work in iMovie at some level other than just the sound. Or, you can continue to try using an unworkable video that is too high res for the app. That's your call, of course. I am just trying to give you a way forward.


You might also try the 30 day free trial of FCPX recommended by thesurreyfriends.


-- Rich

Feb 21, 2020 10:52 AM in response to Rich839

Thank you Rich for your answer, however its not helpful, you are wrong.

The (not working) recording is actually h.264 and my suspicion is that the format level is too high: 5.2. for iMovie. At Apple website it is only written that it handles h.264 without any details about levels.


Btw, iMovie accepts 4k 60fps - it handles my videos taken by gopro camera. The difference is that the gopro recordings are in HEVC format.

So I consider buying FCP, but don’t know if it helps me.

Feb 22, 2020 8:19 AM in response to Rich839

What I have found is that iMovie will knock down a 4k 60fps video to 4K 30fps in the timeline. Try this experiment and see if you get the same findings that I did:


Place a 4k 60fps clip in the timeline as the first clip added to a newly created project. Expand your timeline with the slider that is located next to the Settings button to the right of your screen just above the timeline. Now put your cursor on the clip and, while holding down the "r" key slowly press-drag your cursor to the right. A little frame counter box will appear that counts the frames as you drag. If, when the counter reaches 00:29 frames on the next tick it changes to 01:00 second, that means that the clip is 30fps and will export at 30fps. If it reaches 00:59 frames before it clicks to 01:00 second, that means that the clip is 60fps.


-- Rich



iMovie doesn’t read avc high L5.2 movie

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.