You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Editing in Apple photos App

I'm editing ( I think) RAW images in the Photos App but am unsure how the interaction with iCloud works. If I click on a photo that is already in the cloud am I editing a thumbnail vs the RAW image? Should I take Photos off iCloud until I have finished editing? What is the best approach?


John G

Posted on Mar 23, 2023 2:11 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Mar 23, 2023 7:27 AM

If you have "Copy Originals" checked in Photos>Settings>iCloud, then you will be editing the full image and, when you're through, that edited image will be automatically copied to iCloud.


If you have "Optimize Storage" checked, instead, then Photos will automatically download the full sized image from iCloud for you to work on, and then it will be automatically copied back to iCloud.


Of course, you have to be connected to the internet for all that automatic stuff to happen.


Edited pictures are jpegs.


See this:

How the Photos app and iCloud Photos handle RAW images - Apple Support


4 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Mar 23, 2023 7:27 AM in response to Tragopan10

If you have "Copy Originals" checked in Photos>Settings>iCloud, then you will be editing the full image and, when you're through, that edited image will be automatically copied to iCloud.


If you have "Optimize Storage" checked, instead, then Photos will automatically download the full sized image from iCloud for you to work on, and then it will be automatically copied back to iCloud.


Of course, you have to be connected to the internet for all that automatic stuff to happen.


Edited pictures are jpegs.


See this:

How the Photos app and iCloud Photos handle RAW images - Apple Support


Mar 23, 2023 12:50 PM in response to Tragopan10

A bit of additional background information. There should be no difference between editing RAW files and JPEGs, and whether you are using iCloud Photos or not,as long as your camera model is on the list of supported camera models for your system version (Digital camera RAW formats supported by iOS 16, iPadOS 16, and macOS Ventura - Apple Support) and as long as you are having enough free storage on your Mac to download the originals from iCloud.

  • iCloud Photos is automatically keeping the photos on your mac in sync with iCloud. The central storage of the Photos Library will be in iCloud, but the library is mirrored on your mac. All edits you apply on your Mac will be synced to iCloud Photos and from there to your other devices. If all is well, we should not even notice the syncing with iCloud.
  • Photos is supporting the lossless workflow. We can always revert all adjustments individually and revert to the original version of a photo. The original image file will never be modified, whether it is a RAW or JPEG or HEIC or any other format. When we edit a photo, the original will remain unchanged and Photos is just storing the sequence of adjustments that needs to be applied. When we add several adjustments, Photos will always start to render the adjustments starting from the original, so rounding errors do not accumulate. When we finish editing, Photos will create a new thumbnail for browsing and a preview for the media browser. The edited version will live in limbo and not be rendered, until we need the photo for Sharing or exporting. When we export the photo, we can specify the size, the quality , and the format we want. The exported version will be rendered by applying the adjustments to the original, for the best quality. Until we export or share an edited photos it does not have any format - it could be any supported format. This will be decided when we export it.


Only, if we use external editors, the edited version will be returned from the external editor as an image in a fixed format, mostly as a TIFF, because this is a lossless format. But it will depend on the external editor. But this image does not replace the original RAW file, it will be saved as an additional version of the image.





Editing in Apple photos App

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.