You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Best Way to Clone a Time Machine Drive

I am re-opening the discussion at Moving Time Machine backup to new drive - Apple Community


I recently moved a 2Tb backup to a 4Tb disk and find it surprising that Apple does not have really have a satisfactory solution. I read many blogs and reviews that say Finder is not a good method but after trying several alternatives, including Disk Utility, I have to agree that Finder is the best free solution for copying Time Machine disks.


It is annoying that it has a long 'preparation' step with no progress indication, after which user interaction is required; and it does not confirm when copy is complete (it just closes the window), but it does show progress when actually copying.


It is important to format the new Time Machine disk correctly first (to MacOS Extended (Journaled) because Finder will not warn you of a wrong format; you will only find out it does not work when you try to activate it in Time Machine.


Here is a summary of all my trials, all on MacOS Catalina on an iMac with 3.2MHz quad core i5 processor (nothing extraordinary). It took around 6 hours to copy 1Tb.


Carbon Copy Cloner           NOT SUITABLE       Refuses to copy Time Machine drive


ChronoSync  NOT SUITABLE       Looks like a good way of synchronising folders, but will not copy a disk


Disk Utility (MacOS) NOT SUITABLE       It said 'Backup disk not valid for restoring".


Do Your Clone          NOT FREE for cloning        Looks simple to use, but requires activiation to clone.


EaseUS Todo           NOT SUITABLE       Does backups, not cloning


Finder (MacOS)           OK. Apple-recommended method. Work but is not perfect.  Annoying 'preparation' step after which user interaction required before copying, but does copy reliably and gives progress bar with time estimated to complete. Does not confirm completiojn (progress bar disappears when finished).


Stellar Drive Clone   NOT SUITABLE       Will not run on a 64-bit machine!


SuperDuper  FAILED          Started OK but does not give estimated time remaining. Stopped part way for no apparent reason!.


True Image   NOT FREE for cloning        Cloning only available in the full version




iMac 27″, macOS 10.15

Posted on Jan 13, 2021 3:41 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 13, 2021 11:37 AM

The reason it takes a long time in preparing is that the TM backup is an complex ecosystem of hard links and permissions.


Say File A is backed up in the first backup and never changed again. All subsequent backups of that file are hard links pointing back to the original. When cloning via the Finder every file is examined and hard links verified before backing up proceeds. It's a long process but the hard links allow for many, many backups to be make with minimal space used.


Similar questions

3 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jan 13, 2021 11:37 AM in response to AndyEdinburgh

The reason it takes a long time in preparing is that the TM backup is an complex ecosystem of hard links and permissions.


Say File A is backed up in the first backup and never changed again. All subsequent backups of that file are hard links pointing back to the original. When cloning via the Finder every file is examined and hard links verified before backing up proceeds. It's a long process but the hard links allow for many, many backups to be make with minimal space used.


Best Way to Clone a Time Machine Drive

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.